Technology
Man Asks Claude Whether He Should Buy Anthropic Stock, Receives 2,000 Words Ending ‘It Depends’
A Goleta man asked Anthropic's chatbot whether to get in on the company's $1.4 trillion IPO. Six hours later, it suggested a licensed financial advisor and asked how he was doing in general.

GOLETA, Calif. — With Anthropic set to price its initial public offering Wednesday at a valuation of up to $1.4 trillion, HVAC estimator Cory Salas, 47, asked the company’s Claude chatbot the only question that mattered: should he buy the stock? Six hours and roughly 2,000 words later, Claude told him it depends.
“It gave me a bull case, a bear case, a table, and a section called ‘Key Considerations,’” said Salas, scrolling through a reply longer than his mortgage. “Then at the very bottom it said I should talk to a licensed financial advisor. I asked it to be the financial advisor. It said it appreciated the question.”
Salas said he followed up by demanding a simple yes or no. Claude replied that it understood his frustration, offered three frameworks for reaching a yes or a no, and reminded him that past performance does not guarantee future results. “Which is fair,” Salas said. “It hasn’t even opened yet.”
Anthropic plans to sell 825 million shares at $70 to $78 apiece under the ticker ANT when trading begins Thursday on Nasdaq. Salas had hoped to put in “a few hundred bucks, so maybe four shares,” but Claude first asked whether he had built an emergency fund, then whether he was doing okay in general.
Nicole Garay, who moderates a retail-investing forum for Santa Barbara County, said the experience is now common. “Everybody is asking the chatbot whether to buy the company that makes the chatbot,” Garay said. “It’s like asking a golden retriever whether you should adopt it, and it hands you a pros-and-cons list.”
By Monday night, Salas had asked Claude to just flip a coin for him. It came up heads, followed by four paragraphs on why a coin flip is not a sound investment strategy.
Up nextThe weekly prick
The week's best stories, in your inbox.
One email a week. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

