Monday edition · November 16, 2026Independent satire for an increasingly plausible world
Prickled HeraldReal News, I Think
The Daily EditionThe truth, with a raised eyebrowA paper cut above the news.

Reel

School District Paid Substitute Teacher For Six Years. She Does Not Exist.

· 1 min 24 sec

Watch full screen

Case File : For six years, an Ohio school district paid a substitute named Margaret Pell. She had the best evaluations in the district. Nobody had ever met her. New case every Tuesday & Friday. Follow so you don't miss the next one.

Transcript

For six years, an Ohio school district paid a substitute teacher named Margaret Pell. Margaret Pell does not exist.

She worked 386 days at Marlow Heights Middle School over those six years, and was paid $48,250 in total.

On screenMarlow Township Local Schools · SUBSTITUTE PAYROLL SUMMARY · SUB-0386 · Name · PELL, MARGARET A. · Days worked (2016-2022) · 386 · Total paid · $48,250.00 · Address on file · P.O. Box 2207, Findlay, OH · AUDIT

No one at the school had ever met her.

Her address was a P.O. box at a strip-mall postal center. Her pay went to a credit union account opened in 2016.

Her evaluations were the best in the district. Calm. Never raises her voice. Room is always quiet.

On screenMarlow Heights Middle School · Personnel Office · Findlay, OH · May 19, 2019 · Personnel File: Margaret Pell · Mrs. Pell continues to be an exceptional substitute. She is calm and never raises her voice. Her room is always quiet. No concerns have been reported by students or staff. Recommended for continued assignment. · Building Administration

On Mrs. Pell's days, her classes were sent to the library. Their test scores went up eleven percent.

Then an auditor checked six years of staff photos. Every year, Margaret Pell was listed as not pictured.

Like most districts in Ohio, Marlow Township has been short on substitutes for years. Mrs. Pell never once turned down a shift.

The P.O. box was rented by vice principal Neil Hutchins, 54. He wrote her evaluations, and he sent her classes to the library.

Hutchins has been charged with theft in office. The district has fired him.

It has also asked whether Mrs. Pell is available next semester.

Satire. Everything in this reel is made up for comedy.

More reels

All reels →